The Effect of Dynamic Out-of-Phase Operation of Synchronous Generators on the Short-Circuit Currents in Electric Power Systems
Abstract
The growing levels of short-circuit currents (SCC) in electric power systems (EPS) generate the need of improving the SCC calculation methods. Factors causing the occurrence of dynamic out-of-phase operation of synchronous generators (SGs) and its effect on the SCC are studied. To analyze the effect the out-of-phase operation of SGs has on the SCC, an analysis model was developed in the EMTP-RV software package (Powersys, France), and variant calculations were carried out. The study was carried out for an SG operating in parallel with the EPS. The parameters of electrical equipment installed in the EPS of Russia and CIS countries were used as initial data. The effects the mechanical inertia and electromagnetic parameters of the rotor and stator windings have on the occurrence of out-of-phase operation of generators was considered. It is shown that the analysis of SCC carried out without taking into account the dynamic out-of-phase operation of SGs yields SCC values significantly overestimated in comparison with those calculated according to the standards that are currently in force. By the short-circuit clearing time, the initial phase of the SCC component from the SG may differ from the initial phase of the SCC component from the network source by 90 degrees or more; i.e., the total SCC obtained taking into account the SG current phase becomes less than the current from the network source. It is recommended to take into account the dynamic out-of-phase operation of SGs in solving matters concerned with coordinating the SCC levels and to improve methods for calculating SCC in the EPS.
References
1. АРМ СРЗА – Полная документация: Официальный сайт разработчиков АРМ СРЗА [Электрон. ресурс] http://www.pk-briz.ru/node/145 (дата обращения 10.02.2021).
2. Шмойлов А.В. Расчет электрических величин при повреждениях в электрических системах и уставок токовой защиты с помощью пакета программ ТКЗ-3000: Учебно-методическое пос. Томск: Изд.ТПУ, 2010, 85 с.
3. ГОСТ Р 52735-2007. Короткие замыкания в электроустановках. Методы расчета в электроустановках переменного тока напряжением свыше 1 кВ. М.: Стандартинформ, 2008, 36с.
4. IEC 60909-0-2016. Short-circuit currents in three phases А.С. systems Part 0: Calculation of currents, Ed.2.0 2001-16, 149 p.
5. Stojanovic D. P., Nahman J. M., Veselinovic M. O. Generator Dinamic Influence on Currents Distributionst in Fault Condition, Paper published in: MELECON 99th International Conference on Power System Transients. Proceedings, June 20–24, Budapesht, Hungary,1999.
6. Ruan Qiantu. Present situation of short circuit current control in Shanghai power grid and countermeasures. – Power System Technology, 2005, voI.29(2), pp.78–83.
7. Крючков И.П., Старшинов В.А., Гусев Ю.П., Пиратов М.В. Переходные процессы в электроэнергетических системах: Учебник для вузов / Под ред. И.П. Крючкова. М.: Издательский дом МЭИ, 2008, 416 с.
8. Cуворов А.А., Гусев А.С., Андреев М.В., Аскаров А.Б. Всережимная верификация расчётов при анализе динамической устойчивости электроэнергетических систем. – Электричество, 2020, № 11, с. 28–37.
9. Papadopoulos T. A., Kalaoudas Ch. G., Papadopoulos P. N., Marinopoulos A. G., Papagiannis G. K. Static and Dinamic Calculation of Short–Circuit Currents in Synchronous Generators. Paper published in: International Conference on Power Systems. Transients (IPST2011) in Delft, the Netherlands June 14–17, 2011.
10. Stojanovic D. P., Nahman J. M., Veselinovic M. O. Calculation and analysis of generator dynamics influence on short circuit current, Paper published in: MELECON '98. 9th Mediterranean Electrotechnical Conference. Proceedings (Cat. No.98CH36056) Tel–Aviv, Israel, 18–20 May, 1998.
11. Гусев Ю.П., Каюмов А.Г., Говорин В.В. Учет несинфазности генераторов при расчетах токов в начальный момент короткого замыкания. – Вестник МЭИ, 2019, № 4, с. 11–17.
12. Гуревич Ю. Е., Либова Л. Е., Окин А. А. Расчеты устойчивости и противоаварийной автоматики в энергосистемах. М.: Энергоатомиздат, 1990, 390 с.
13. Uqaili M. A., Sahito A. A., Halepoto I. A., Memon Z. A., Dars S. B. Impact of distributed generation on network short circuit level. 2014 4th International Conference on Wireless Communications, Vehicular Technology, Information Theory and Aerospace & Electronics Systems (VITAE), 2014. doi:10.1109/vitae.2014.6934455.
14. Tu X., Dessaint L.-A., Fallati N., De Kelper B. Modeling and Real-Time Simulation of Internal Faults in Synchronous Generators with Parallel-Connected Windings. – IEEE Transactions on Industrial Electronics, 2007, vol. 54(3), pp. 1400–1409. doi:10.1109/tie.2007.892004.
15. Гусев Ю.П., Каюмов А.Г., Говорин В.В. Влияние систем возбуждения синхронных генераторов на несинфазность токов короткого замыкания в электроэнергетической системе. – Релейная защита и автоматизация, 2019, № 3, с.30–33.
16. Руководящие указания по релейной защите. Выпуск 11. Расчеты токов короткого замыкания для релейной защиты и системной автоматики в сетях 110-750 кВ. М.: Энергия, 1979, 152 с.
#
1. ARM SRZA [Electron Resource] http://www.pk-briz.ru/node/145 (Date of appeal 10.02.2021).
2. Shmoylov A. V. Raschet elektricheskih velichin pri povrezhdeniyah v elektricheskih sistemah i ustavok tokovoj zashchity s pomoshch'yu paketa programm TKZ-3000: uchebno-metod. pos. (Calculation of electrical values in case of damage in electrical systems and current protection setpoints using the TKZ-3000 software package: a tutorial). Tomsk: Izd. TPU, 2010, 85 p.
3. GOST R 52735-2007. Korotkie zamykaniya v elektroustanovkah. Metody rascheta v elektroustanovkah peremennogo toka napryazheniem svyshe 1 kV (Short-circuits in electrical installations. Calculation methods in alternating current electrical installations with voltage above 1 kV). М.: Standartinform, 2008, 36с.
4. IEC 60909-0-2016. Short-circuit currents in three phases А.С. systems Part 0: Calculation of currents, Ed.2.0 2001-16, 149 p.
5. Stojanovic D. P., Nahman J. M., Veselinovic M. O. Generator Dinamic Influence on Currents Distributionst in Fault Condition, Paper published in: MELECON 99th International Conference on Power System Transients. Proceedings, June 20–24, Budapesht, Hungary,1999.
6. Ruan Qiantu. Present situation of short circuit current control in Shanghai power grid and countermeasures. – Power System Technology, 2005, voI.29(2), pp.78–83.
7. Kryuchkov I.P., Starshinov V.A., Gusev Yu.P., Piratov M.V. Perekhodnye processy v elektroenergeticheskih sistemah: uchebnik dlya vuzov / Pod red. I.P. Kryuchkova (Transients in electric power systems: textbook for universities). М.: Izdatel'skiy dom MEI, 2008, 416 p.
8. Suvorov A. A., Gusev A. S., Andreev M. V., Askarov A. B. Elektrichestvo – in Russ. (Electricity), 2020, No. 11, pp. 28–37.
9. Papadopoulos T. A., Kalaoudas Ch. G., Papadopoulos P. N., Marinopoulos A. G., Papagiannis G. K. Static and Dinamic Calculation of Short–Circuit Currents in Synchronous Generators. Paper published in: International Conference on Power Systems. Transients (IPST2011) in Delft, the Netherlands June 14–17, 2011.
10. Stojanovic D. P., Nahman J. M., Veselinovic M. O. Calculation and analysis of generator dynamics influence on short circuit current, Paper published in: MELECON '98. 9th Mediterranean Electrotechnical Conference. Proceedings (Cat. No.98CH36056) Tel–Aviv, Israel, 18–20 May, 1998.
11. Gusev Yu. P., Kayumov A. G., Govorin V. V. Vestnik MEI – in Russ.(Bulletin of MPEI), 2019, No. 4, pp. 11–17.
12. Gurevich Yu. E., Libova L. E., Okin A. A. Raschety` ustojchivosti i protivoavarijnoj avtomatiki v e`nergosistemax (Calculations of Stability and Emergency Automation in Power Systems). М.: Energoatomizdat, 1990, 390 p.
13. Uqaili M. A., Sahito A. A., Halepoto I. A., Memon Z. A., Dars S. B. Impact of distributed generation on network short circuit level. 2014 4th International Conference on Wireless Communications, Vehicular Technology, Information Theory and Aerospace & Electronics Systems (VITAE), 2014. doi:10.1109/vitae.2014.6934455.
14. Tu X., Dessaint L.-A., Fallati N., De Kelper B. Modeling and Real-Time Simulation of Internal Faults in Synchronous Generators with Parallel-Connected Windings. – IEEE Transactions on Industrial Electronics, 2007, vol. 54(3), pp. 1400–1409. doi:10.1109/tie.2007.892004.
15. Gusev Yu. P., Kayumov A. G., Govorin V. V. Relejnaya zashhita i avtomatizaciya – in Russ. (Relay Protection and Automation), 2019, No. 3, pp.30–33.
16. Rukovodyashchie ukazaniya po relejnoj zashchite. Vypusk 11. Raschety tokov korotkogo zamykaniya dlya relejnoj zashchity i sistemnoj avtomatiki v setyah 110-750 kV (Guidelines for relay protection. Issue 11. Calculations of short-circuit currents for relay protection and system automation in 110-750 kV networks). М.: Energiya, 1979, 152 p.
